Comparison 7 min read

New vs. Existing Apartments in Flemington: A Detailed Comparison

New vs. Existing Apartments in Flemington: A Detailed Comparison

Choosing between a new and an existing apartment in Flemington is a crucial decision for any prospective buyer. Both options offer unique advantages and disadvantages. This detailed comparison will explore the key factors to consider, helping you make an informed choice that aligns with your needs and financial goals.

Why Flemington?

Flemington is a vibrant suburb known for its proximity to Melbourne's CBD, excellent transport links, and a diverse community. Its appeal lies in its blend of urban convenience and leafy residential streets. Whether you're a young professional, a family, or a retiree, Flemington offers a range of lifestyle options.

1. Cost and Financing Options

One of the primary considerations when buying an apartment is the cost. This includes the purchase price, stamp duty, legal fees, and ongoing expenses.

New Apartments

Purchase Price: New apartments often come with a higher purchase price compared to existing apartments, reflecting modern design, new appliances, and developer margins. However, some developers offer incentives like stamp duty concessions or appliance packages.
Stamp Duty: In Victoria, stamp duty is a significant cost. It's calculated based on the property's value. Our services can help you understand potential stamp duty implications.
Financing: Securing finance for a new apartment can sometimes be easier, especially if the developer has pre-approved lenders. Off-the-plan purchases often require a smaller deposit initially, with the balance due upon completion.
First Home Owner Grant: First-time buyers may be eligible for the First Home Owner Grant, which can provide a significant financial boost. Eligibility criteria vary, so it's essential to check the current requirements.

Existing Apartments

Purchase Price: Existing apartments generally have a lower purchase price, making them more accessible for some buyers. However, they may require renovations or upgrades.
Stamp Duty: Stamp duty applies to existing apartments as well, calculated on the purchase price.
Financing: Financing for existing apartments is typically straightforward, with lenders assessing the property's value and the buyer's financial situation.
Negotiation: There's often more room for negotiation with existing apartments, as sellers may be more motivated to sell. You can leverage this to secure a better price.

2. Design and Features

The design and features of an apartment play a significant role in its appeal and functionality.

New Apartments

Modern Design: New apartments boast contemporary designs, open-plan layouts, and high-quality finishes. They often incorporate the latest trends in interior design.
New Appliances: New apartments come equipped with brand-new appliances, covered by warranties. This can save you money on replacements and repairs in the initial years.
Customisation: Depending on the stage of construction, you may have the opportunity to customise certain aspects of the apartment, such as colour schemes, flooring, and fixtures.
Amenities: Many new apartment complexes offer amenities like gyms, swimming pools, rooftop terraces, and communal gardens. These can enhance your lifestyle and provide added convenience.

Existing Apartments

Established Character: Existing apartments often have unique character and charm, reflecting the architectural style of their era. They may feature original details like ornate cornices, high ceilings, and hardwood floors.
Larger Sizes: Older apartments are often larger than new apartments, offering more living space. This can be a significant advantage for families or those who value space.
Renovation Potential: Existing apartments offer the opportunity to renovate and customise the space to your liking. This allows you to create a home that perfectly suits your needs and style.
Established Gardens: Older apartment buildings often have established gardens and landscaping, creating a more mature and inviting environment.

3. Maintenance and Repairs

Maintenance and repairs are ongoing costs that need to be factored into your budget.

New Apartments

Lower Initial Maintenance: New apartments typically require less maintenance in the initial years, as everything is new and under warranty.
Building Management: New apartment complexes usually have a building manager who oversees maintenance and repairs. This can save you time and effort.
Owners Corporation Fees: Owners corporation fees cover the cost of maintaining common areas and amenities. These fees can be higher in new apartment complexes due to the extensive amenities.
Defects: While new, there can be initial defects that need addressing. A thorough inspection is essential before settlement. You can learn more about Flemingtonapartments and how we can help with this.

Existing Apartments

Potential for Repairs: Existing apartments may require repairs and upgrades, especially if they haven't been well-maintained. This can include plumbing, electrical, and structural work.
Higher Maintenance Costs: Older apartments may have higher maintenance costs due to aging infrastructure and appliances.
Special Levies: Owners corporation may impose special levies to cover major repairs or upgrades. These levies can be substantial and unexpected.
Established Owners Corporation: Existing buildings typically have a well-established owners corporation with a track record of managing the building.

4. Capital Growth Potential

Capital growth is the increase in the value of your property over time. It's a key factor to consider when buying an apartment as an investment.

New Apartments

Potential for Higher Growth: New apartments may have higher capital growth potential due to their modern design, new amenities, and appeal to a wider range of buyers. However, this can be impacted by oversupply in certain areas.
Depreciation Benefits: Investors can claim depreciation on new apartments, reducing their taxable income.
Location: The location of the new apartment complex is crucial. Proximity to transport, schools, shops, and amenities can significantly impact capital growth.

Existing Apartments

Proven Track Record: Existing apartments have a proven track record of capital growth. You can research the historical price trends in the area to assess their potential.
Established Neighbourhood: Existing apartments are typically located in established neighbourhoods with existing infrastructure and amenities. This can provide stability and predictability.
Renovation Potential: Renovating an existing apartment can increase its value and capital growth potential.
Scarcity: In some areas, older, larger apartments are becoming increasingly scarce, which can drive up their value.

5. Environmental Considerations

Environmental considerations are becoming increasingly important to buyers. This includes energy efficiency, water conservation, and sustainable building materials.

New Apartments

Energy Efficiency: New apartments are typically designed with energy efficiency in mind, incorporating features like double-glazed windows, insulation, and energy-efficient appliances. This can reduce your energy bills and carbon footprint.
Water Conservation: New apartments often include water-saving fixtures and rainwater harvesting systems.
Sustainable Materials: Some developers are using sustainable building materials, such as recycled timber and low-VOC paints.
Green Star Rating: Look for apartments with a Green Star rating, which indicates that the building has been designed and constructed to meet high environmental standards.

Existing Apartments

Retrofitting: Existing apartments can be retrofitted with energy-efficient features, such as insulation, double-glazed windows, and solar panels. This can improve their environmental performance and reduce your energy bills.
Sustainable Renovations: When renovating an existing apartment, you can choose sustainable materials and practices.
Community Gardens: Some older apartment buildings have community gardens, which can promote sustainable living and social interaction.

  • Lower Embodied Energy: Existing buildings have lower embodied energy compared to new buildings, as they don't require the extraction and processing of new materials.


Ultimately, the best choice between a new and an existing apartment in Flemington depends on your individual circumstances, priorities, and budget. Consider your lifestyle, financial goals, and environmental values when making your decision. Don't hesitate to seek professional advice from real estate agents, financial advisors, and building inspectors to ensure you make the right choice. You can also consult our frequently asked questions for more information.

Related Articles

Overview • 6 min

The Future of Flemington Real Estate: An Outlook

Guide • 2 min

A Guide to Investing in Flemington Apartments

Overview • 2 min

Flemington Lifestyle and Amenities Guide

Want to own Flemingtonapartments?

This premium domain is available for purchase.

Make an Offer